The case of a Poland man with identified schizophrenia charged within the Thanksgiving homicide of his brother has reignited debate between advocates who disagree on the best way to greatest serve individuals with critical psychological sicknesses.
Justin Butterfield, 34, is charged with the intentional or realizing or wicked indifference homicide of his brother, Gabriel Damour, 38.
Damour’s homicide displays a failure in Maine’s psychological well being system, the brothers’ family members and a few advocates mentioned.
Justin Butterfield Submitted picture
There have been a number of missed alternatives to get Butterfield into Maine’s progressive remedy program, Butterfield’s former girlfriend, Yaicha Provencher, with whom he shares two kids, mentioned at a press conference Monday.
The progressive remedy program was established by a 2010 legislation by then-Sen. John Nutting of Leeds. The legislation permits sure medical suppliers, legislation enforcement officers or a authorized guardian to use for an order from the Maine District Court docket to confess an individual with a “extreme or persistent psychological sickness” and who poses a probability of significant hurt, to this system.
Below this system, which can embrace involuntary hospitalization, an individual admitted is required beneath the legislation to observe a remedy program.
However Maine barely makes use of this legislation to get individuals into remedy and state officers have known as it a “final resort,” mentioned Nutting, who additionally organized Monday’s convention.
“Simply how final ditch do it’s a must to be when persons are getting abused in emergency rooms — workers is — and persons are getting killed? … You proceed to place individuals out over and over and over on the ‘cross your fingers’ plan,” he mentioned.
“We’re simply not utilizing the legislation wherever close to the way in which we must always, not wherever as a lot as we must always, in our opinion,” Nutting mentioned.
“And it’s simply very, very irritating as a result of Mr. Butterfield was an accomplished mechanic. They appreciated him at work when he was on his remedy plan. And so, you understand, Maine is making it so exhausting to provoke remedy once they don’t suppose they should after which we’re getting all these horrible outcomes which can be simply so tragic and pointless.”
However standing in the way in which is Maine’s federally funded, nonprofit advocacy group, Incapacity Rights Maine, Nutting mentioned.
It’s true that Incapacity Rights publicly spoke towards the 2010 invoice that established the progressive remedy program, Mark Joyce, DRME’s lead counsel for psychological well being advocacy, mentioned Friday.
However the invoice handed and “the legislation is the legislation.”
As for why DRME advocated towards it, “we oppose these kind of pressured neighborhood psychological well being remedy legal guidelines as a result of for one factor, we all know of no, like, peer evaluation, randomized research suggesting {that a} court-ordered dedication — committing people to an assertive neighborhood remedy or ACT workforce — for psychological well being remedy alone improves remedy outcomes,” he mentioned.
Justin Butterfield, who has identified schizophrenia, is charged with homicide within the killing of his brother in Poland on Thanksgiving. Family and friends say Maine’s damaged psychological well being system is accountable. Andree Kehn/Solar Journal file
As a result of this system “commits” an individual to remedy from an ACT workforce, “it could work for a choose variety of individuals, however what we’ve seen is that when a neighborhood psychological well being system has in it the potential for pressured remedy, it discourages individuals from in search of any remedy.”
Bangor resident Joe Pickering mentioned the state has failed to just accept extra sources that may broaden companies for Mainers with psychological sickness, together with accepting a waiver from the U.S. Facilities for Medicare & Medicaid Providers that may pay for short-term residential remedy companies, a so-called IMD (establishment for psychological illness) waiver.
He, too, pointed to Incapacity Rights Maine, who objected to accepting the IMD waiver.
“That’s completely idiotic. And it’s not solely idiotic, it’s devastatingly disgusting and damaging to Mainers,” mentioned Pickering, who was director of Bangor-based Group Well being and Counseling Providers for 3 a long time.
Pickering’s son, Christopher, died in 2020 from an unintentional hearth that began in his kitchen. Pickering mentioned his son seemingly fell asleep and left the range on.
When Christopher was in his late teenagers to early 20s, he started displaying indicators of schizophrenia, a critical and lifelong mind dysfunction that may impair an individual’s notion of actuality. The illness could cause persistent episodes of psychosis, together with hallucinations and delusions.
Pickering mentioned that whereas Christopher’s loss of life was indirectly associated to his schizophrenia or the IMD waiver, “he was clearly declining. No query about that,” he mentioned.
The IMD waiver would go towards the 1990 settlement settlement in a category motion lawsuit introduced towards the state on behalf of residents of the now-defunct Augusta Psychological Well being Institute, Joyce mentioned.
In a 2019 letter to the Division of Well being and Human Providers, Joyce wrote that “the Division’s waiver software is constructed on an unfounded premise that there’s a want for extra beds in institutional settings.”
This can be a “defective logic,” that might improve “pointless institutionalization” somewhat than rising entry to neighborhood psychological well being companies.
“That is the irritating half … all people’s on the identical web page with getting individuals companies. (This) challenge with the PTP and this stuff, sure, we disagree with their effectiveness however they’re the legislation,” Joyce mentioned.
“The legislation permits for all this involuntary remedy however you’re not going to have the ability to maintain any person within the hospital without end. You’re going to have to determine a means (to) discharge them with the fitting companies,” Joyce mentioned. “And in order that’s the place I believe it breaks down. It’s like, what sort of companies can be found?”
Pickering, Nutting and others, like Jeanne Gore of the Maine-based Nationwide Shattering Silence Coalition, did say they don’t want extra individuals with psychological sickness to be involuntary hospitalized. However they do need to see a “complete array” of community-based companies that they mentioned Maine is missing.
Provencher, Butterfield’s ex-girlfriend, mentioned the shortage of neighborhood helps contributed to Butterfield’s decline.
“What was he anticipated to do when he acquired out? Was a person on this psychotic state anticipated to seek out sources on the market to assist him with one thing he believed he didn’t need assistance with?” she mentioned.
“So what does it take? It has taken a person, who was a loving household man, brutally killing his brother. He took him in from homelessness to assist him as a result of he cherished him. And is it sufficient but? Does he lastly get allowed his proper to remedy or does he get thrown in jail prosecuted and punished for others’ negligence?”
Associated Tales
Invalid username/password.
Please verify your e mail to verify and full your registration.
Use the shape under to reset your password. Once you’ve submitted your account e mail, we’ll ship an e mail with a reset code.