NewsFeed365
  • Home
  • Legal Affairs
  • Lawsuit
  • Advocacy
  • Attorneys
  • Lawyers
  • Litigation
  • Solicitor
No Result
View All Result
NewsFeed365
No Result
View All Result
Is the word ‘alien’ objectionable? Federal appeals judge sees ‘no need to bowdlerize’ decisions and laws

Is the word ‘alien’ objectionable? Federal appeals judge sees ‘no need to bowdlerize’ decisions and laws

News Admin by News Admin
June 6, 2023
in Legal Affairs
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


  1. Home
  2. Daily News
  3. Is the phrase ‘alien’ objectionable? Federal…

Judiciary

Is the phrase ‘alien’ objectionable? Federal appeals decide sees ‘no have to bowdlerize’ choices and legal guidelines

By Debra Cassens Weiss

June 5, 2023, 12:21 pm CDT

Judge James Ho

Choose James C. Photograph from the fifth U.S. Circuit Courtroom of Appeals at New Orleans.

A federal appeals decide who announced plans to boycott Yale Legislation Faculty college students for clerkships is taking purpose at his colleagues for utilizing the phrase “noncitizen” as an alternative of “alien.”

Choose James C. Ho of the fifth U.S. Circuit Courtroom of Appeals at New Orleans made his level in a May 30 concurrence famous by Bloomberg Law and Above the Law.

“I see no have to bowdlerize statutes or judicial choices that use the phrase ‘alien’ by substituting phrases like ‘noncitizen,’” he wrote.

“The phrase ‘alien’ is ubiquitous in statutes, rules, judicial choices and scholarly commentary on federal immigration regulation,” Ho wrote. “However regardless of this established utilization, some members of the judiciary have not too long ago begun to sign their opposition to utilizing that time period, on the bottom that it’s ‘offensive.’ … Respectfully, I don’t share in that sentiment.”

Ho stated he was admitted into the US “as an alien” earlier than he turned a citizen.

“Alien” will be discovered “in numerous judicial choices” and is “utilized in quite a few acts of Congress—together with those that allowed me to develop into an American,” Ho stated.

Some judges are involved that “alien” can recommend that somebody is unusual, totally different or repugnant, Ho wrote.

“That could be true in sure contexts. The phrase additionally refers to extraterrestrials in different contexts,” he wrote.

Within the context of immigration regulation, nevertheless, “alien” merely describes an individual’s authorized standing, Ho stated.

Ho cited one other decide who additionally sees nothing improper with “alien”—Choose Carlos T. Bea of the ninth Circuit at San Francisco. Bea, who was born in Spain, wrote about the issue in a September 2022 concurrence.

Ho additionally cited Bryan A. Garner, editor-in-chief of Black’s Legislation Dictionary and an ABA Journal columnist. A 2011 version of Garner’s Dictionary of Authorized Utilization states that: “Unlawful alien is just not an opprobrious epithet: It describes one current in a rustic in violation of the immigration legal guidelines.”

However Garner provided a nuanced remark to Bloomberg Legislation in an electronic mail.

“Though ‘alien’ in authorized prose was not meant to belittle, the favored connotations of the phrase have inevitably contaminated some individuals’s view of it,” Garner stated. “The linguistic traces have now been drawn as a part of the tradition wars.”

“Solely time will inform how the language will settle the difficulty,” Garner added. “In the intervening time, ‘alien’ doesn’t seem to have a shiny future.”





Source link

You might also like

Lowering of SUD Treatment Barriers Marks AAFP Advocacy … – AAFP News

Neurocrine Biosciences Inc's Chief Legal Officer Darin Lippoldt Sells … – Yahoo Finance

November 30, 2023
US DOJ announces indictment against India national for assassination plot against Sikh separatist – JURIST

US DOJ announces indictment against India national for assassination plot against Sikh separatist – JURIST

November 29, 2023
Tags: alienAppealsbowdlerizeDecisionsFederaljudgeLawsobjectionableseesword
News Admin

News Admin

Related Stories

Lowering of SUD Treatment Barriers Marks AAFP Advocacy … – AAFP News

Neurocrine Biosciences Inc's Chief Legal Officer Darin Lippoldt Sells … – Yahoo Finance

by News Admin
November 30, 2023
0

Neurocrine Biosciences Inc's Chief Legal Officer Darin Lippoldt Sells ...  Yahoo Finance Source link

US DOJ announces indictment against India national for assassination plot against Sikh separatist – JURIST

US DOJ announces indictment against India national for assassination plot against Sikh separatist – JURIST

by News Admin
November 29, 2023
0

The US Division of Justice (DOJ) announced on Wednesday an indictment in opposition to an Indian nationwide named Nikhil Gupta...

Lowering of SUD Treatment Barriers Marks AAFP Advocacy … – AAFP News

Senior CPC official meets with Singapore's chief justice – People's Daily

by News Admin
November 29, 2023
0

Senior CPC official meets with Singapore's chief justice  Folks's Each day Source link

ABA announces 2024 Spirit of Excellence Award recipients

ABA announces 2024 Spirit of Excellence Award recipients

by News Admin
November 29, 2023
0

Home Daily News ABA proclaims 2024 Spirit of Excellence Award… Variety ABA proclaims 2024 Spirit of Excellence Award recipients By...

Next Post
Lowering of SUD Treatment Barriers Marks AAFP Advocacy … – AAFP News

U.S. Attorney Vanessa Waldref administers the oath of office to three ... - bigcountrynewsconnection.com

Recent News

Lowering of SUD Treatment Barriers Marks AAFP Advocacy … – AAFP News

Best DUI Lawyers Las Vegas, NV Of 2023 – Forbes

November 30, 2023
Lowering of SUD Treatment Barriers Marks AAFP Advocacy … – AAFP News

Greenwashing: The Newest Trend In False Advertising Litigation – Lexology

November 30, 2023

Categories

  • Advocacy
  • Attorneys
  • General
  • Lawsuit
  • Lawyers
  • Legal Affairs
  • Litigation
  • Solicitor

Follow Us

Recommended

  • Best DUI Lawyers Las Vegas, NV Of 2023 – Forbes
  • Greenwashing: The Newest Trend In False Advertising Litigation – Lexology
  • Chatham County District Attorney files appeal in discrimination lawsuit – Savannah Morning News
  • Neurocrine Biosciences Inc's Chief Legal Officer Darin Lippoldt Sells … – Yahoo Finance

© 2021 NewsFeed365

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Legal Affairs
  • Lawsuit
  • Advocacy
  • Attorneys
  • Lawyers
  • Litigation
  • Solicitor

© 2021 NewsFeed365