Judge says 3M can’t escape liability in earplug lawsuits

A federal choose just lately instructed 3M that it could not use “dangerous religion manipulation” to keep away from its duty in a slew of circumstances in opposition to the multinational conglomerate for its allegedly faulty earplugs.

In a sharply worded order issued on Dec. 22, U.S. District Choose M. Casey Rodgers, the Pensacola, Florida-based choose the place the practically 250,000 lawsuits in opposition to 3M are being overseen, mentioned the corporate deserved the “harshest penalty” for its effort to shift legal responsibility for listening to harm suffered by veterans to a subsidiary.

“3M purposely engaged in an almost four-year marketing campaign to ascertain itself as the only accountable celebration for [earplug] claims, then abruptly reversed course when that narrative now not suited its strategic targets,” Rodgers wrote.

Based on the choose’s order, 3M’s current transfer got here after it already awarded practically $300,000 to 13 plaintiffs over the course of 16 “bellwether trials.”

The lead legal professionals for the plaintiffs, Bryan Aylstock and Chris Seeger, in a joint assertion welcomed the ruling, Reuters reported.

“We applaud Choose Rodger[s’] order, which shuts the door on 3M’s duplicitous, dangerous religion try and shift blame…in service of its contrived chapter maneuver,” they mentioned.

In August, an try by 3M to have one in all its subsidiaries, Aearo Applied sciences LLC, declare chapter was denied by an Indiana chapter choose, Army Instances beforehand reported. This meant the corporate wouldn’t be allowed to halt litigation in opposition to it and let Aearo Tech take the autumn for one of many largest multidistrict litigations in U.S. historical past.

RELATED

“We disagree with this incomplete and inaccurate depiction of our good religion efforts on this litigation,” 3M mentioned in an announcement, in response to the Minneapolis Star Tribune reported.

The authorized struggle in opposition to 3M began back in 2018. It follows that the Minnesota-based authorities contractor knowingly offered the navy faulty fight earplugs — the dual-ended Fight Arms Earplugs, Model 2 — that didn’t preserve a good sufficient seal, which induced all varieties of listening to harm to service members.

Individually, the latest transfer by the choose comes simply days after the corporate announced in a statement that it could cease making per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances — the poisonous “eternally chemical substances” commonly known as PFAS which the navy is likewise in a battle to handle — by the tip of 2025.

“Whereas PFAS might be safely made and used, we additionally see a chance to steer in a quickly evolving exterior regulatory and enterprise panorama to make the best affect for these we serve,” 3M CEO Mike Roman mentioned within the assertion.